R&D Tax Credit: How It Works After the 174A Change

How the R&D tax credit works after the 174A change: who qualifies, how to calculate it, the startup payroll offset and new Form 6765 rules.

Engineer working on a prototype in a research lab

Last updated: November 7, 2026

Reviewed by a certified public accountant (CPA) on November 10, 2026.

The R&D tax credit gives US businesses back part of what they spend developing or improving products, processes and software. Under the simplified method most companies use, steady research spending earns a credit of roughly 7% of qualified costs, and young companies with little or no income tax can apply up to $500,000 a year against payroll taxes instead.

Short answer: The R&D tax credit is the federal credit for increasing research activities under Internal Revenue Code section 41. It covers wages, supplies, computer rental and 65% of contractor costs for work that clears a four-part test. Most companies claim the 14% alternative simplified credit on Form 6765, and qualified small businesses can apply up to $500,000 a year against payroll taxes.

Key takeaways

  • With flat research spending, the 14% alternative simplified credit comes to 7% of qualified research expenses; companies with no qualified spending in any of the prior three years get 6%.
  • A qualified small business (gross receipts below $5 million and no receipts before the five-year window) can elect up to $500,000 a year against employer payroll taxes.
  • Starting in 2025, domestic research costs are deductible again under section 174A, while foreign research still amortizes over 15 years.
  • Taking the full credit lowers your 174A deduction. The section 280C election trades that for a credit reduced to 79%.
  • Section G of Form 6765 (project-level detail) becomes mandatory for tax years beginning after 2025, with exceptions for smaller claims.

What the R&D tax credit is

The research credit is a general business credit established by section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code, which names it the credit for increasing research activities. It’s claimed on IRS Form 6765. Since a credit reduces tax dollar for dollar, it’s worth much more than a deduction of the same size. Unused amounts usually carry back one year and forward 20 years, according to the IRS instructions for Form 3800.

It isn’t just for labs. The test examines the work, not the industry. A software company building a new matching algorithm, a manufacturer redesigning a part to save weight or an engineering firm creating a new fabrication process can all qualify, provided the project meets the statutory test below.

The R&D tax credit reaches you in one of three ways:

  • As a credit against income tax for companies turning a profit.
  • Passed through to owners of partnerships and S corporations, who apply it on their own returns. The Form 6765 instructions say partnerships and S corporations have to file the form to claim the credit.
  • As a payroll tax offset for young companies with modest revenue, which gets its own section below.
Engineers testing a prototype for an R&D tax credit claim

The four-part test, in plain English

Each project, called a business component in the rules, has to pass all four parts independently. The IRS instructions for Form 6765 lay them out like this:

  1. Section 174A test. The costs have to be treated as domestic research or experimental expenditures under section 174A. In practice, that means costs of developing or improving a product or process when the right design or method wasn’t known at the outset.
  2. Technological in nature. The work must rest on principles of the physical or biological sciences, engineering or computer science.
  3. Business component. The aim is a new or improved product, process, software, technique, formula or invention that you sell or use in your business.
  4. Process of experimentation. Substantially all of the activities (which the regulations interpret as 80% or more) have to involve weighing alternatives to resolve uncertainty about function, performance, reliability or quality.

Part four is where people get caught. A lot of engineering work is skilled but routine. If your team already knew how to build it before starting and just built it, the uncertainty the credit rewards isn’t present.

A quick screen: for each project, write a single sentence answering, “What didn’t we know at the start, and how did we figure it out?” If you can’t answer with specifics, like alternatives tested, prototypes scrapped or benchmarks missed, the project probably doesn’t qualify.

What doesn’t qualify

Section 41(d)(4) spells out exclusions. Work in any of these categories doesn’t count, even when it feels like research:

  • Research done after commercial production of the component starts.
  • Tailoring an existing product to a specific customer’s requirement.
  • Reproducing an existing product from physical examination, plans or specifications.
  • Efficiency surveys, management studies, market research, routine data collection and routine quality-control testing.
  • Research performed outside the United States, Puerto Rico or a US possession.
  • Research in the social sciences, arts or humanities.
  • Research funded by a customer, a grant or a government entity, up to the amount of the funding.

The funded-research exclusion trips up contract developers and agencies more than anyone. Whether research counts as funded generally comes down to two questions: does your payment hinge on the work succeeding, and do you retain substantial rights in the results? Read the contracts before counting those projects.

Qualified research expenses: what counts

Qualified research expenses, or QREs, feed the research credit calculation. The Form 6765 instructions group them as follows:

CategoryWhat it coversShare that counts
In-house wagesTaxable wages of employees who perform, directly supervise or directly support qualified researchThe qualifying share of each person’s wages
SuppliesMaterials used up in research, such as prototype parts; not land, depreciable property or general overhead100%
Computer useAmounts paid to others to rent or lease computers used in qualified research, such as cloud test environments100%
Contract researchPayments to nonemployees for qualified research performed for you65% (75% for qualified research consortia; 100% for certain energy research)
Basic research paymentsCash payments by corporations to universities and certain organizations for basic researchSeparate calculation

Wages usually make up most of it, since research is mainly people’s time. The tricky figure isn’t total payroll but the share of each person’s time spent on qualifying work. Project-level time tracking, sprint records or real-time estimates from project leads give you a defensible percentage. A guess made in March about the previous year doesn’t.

Contract research is easy to overstate. Only 65% of most contractor payments counts, the contractor has to be doing qualified research on your behalf and work done outside the United States is excluded completely. Offshore development teams are a frequent reason claims get cut back.

If you track QREs in spreadsheets, our guide to Claude for Excel for accountants shows ways to speed up reconciling payroll registers with project time.

Research team comparing design alternatives during a project

How the research credit is calculated

There are two methods.

Regular credit. The credit is 20% of QREs above a base amount. The base amount equals a fixed-base percentage, capped at 16%, times your average gross receipts for the four prior years, and it can’t drop below 50% of current-year QREs. For long-established companies, the fixed-base percentage comes from research spending and receipts in 1984 through 1988, which is why few can still document it.

Alternative simplified credit (ASC). The credit is 14% of QREs above 50% of your average QREs for the prior three years. If you had no QREs in any of those three years, the credit is 6% of current-year QREs.

Most companies claiming the research credit go with the ASC, since its inputs are three years of their own research spending instead of decades of receipts data. The Form 6765 instructions point out that an ASC election for the current year can’t be revoked.

The math yields a handy rule of thumb. If your research spending holds flat, the ASC equals 7% of QREs: 14% of the half above the base. Growth lifts the effective rate, and shrinking spending lowers it.

Worked example: the alternative simplified credit

Here’s a hypothetical software company whose research spending is growing. The figures are illustrative.

Tax yearQualified research expenses
2023$400,000
2024$450,000
2025$500,000
2026 (credit year)$600,000
  1. Average QREs over the three prior years: ($400,000 + $450,000 + $500,000) ÷ 3 = $450,000.
  2. Half of that average: $225,000.
  3. Current QREs above that figure: $600,000 − $225,000 = $375,000.
  4. Credit: 14% × $375,000 = $52,500.

That’s 8.75% of 2026 QREs, above the 7% flat-spending benchmark because spending rose. If the company elects the reduced credit under section 280C, covered below, the credit drops to $52,500 × 79% = $41,475.

The payroll tax offset for startups

Section 41(h) allows a qualified small business to apply the research credit against payroll taxes instead of income tax. That matters because most early-stage companies owe no income tax, so an income tax credit would go unused for years. The Form 6765 instructions set out the conditions:

  • Gross receipts below $5 million for the credit year.
  • No gross receipts in any year before the five-tax-year period ending with the credit year.
  • An election of up to $500,000 a year. The Inflation Reduction Act lifted the limit from $250,000 for tax years beginning after December 31, 2022.
  • No election for a year if you’ve already made it for five or more earlier years.
  • The election has to be made by the due date of the original return, extensions included. Revoking it needs IRS consent.

The IRS instructions for Form 8974 say the credit first offsets the employer share of social security tax, up to $250,000 per quarter, with any remainder offsetting the employer share of Medicare tax. It begins with the Form 941 for the first quarter after you file the income tax return making the election, and unused amounts roll to the next quarter. You claim it on Form 8974, attached to Form 941, or to Form 943 or 944 for annual filers.

Worked example: a startup using the payroll offset

Consider a hypothetical calendar-year C corporation founded in 2025. Its first revenue came in 2025, it had $1.8 million in gross receipts in 2026 and $600,000 of QREs in 2026. With no QREs in 2023 or 2024, the 6% rate applies.

  • Credit: 6% × $600,000 = $36,000.
  • Election: it files its 2026 Form 1120 with Form 6765 in March 2027 and elects the payroll offset.
  • Payroll: $300,000 of wages each quarter, with every employee under the social security wage base. Employer social security tax is 6.2% × $300,000 = $18,600 a quarter, and employer Medicare tax is 1.45% × $300,000 = $4,350.
  • Second quarter of 2027: the credit erases $18,600 of social security tax, then $4,350 of Medicare tax, $22,950 in all.
  • Third quarter of 2027: the remaining $13,050 offsets social security tax.

The company converts its research spending into cash within two quarters, even though it owes no income tax. That’s the point of the election, and missing the original-return deadline forfeits it for that year.

How section 174A changed the math in 2025

For tax years 2022 through 2024, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act made companies capitalize research costs and amortize them, over five years for domestic research. Public Law 119-21, signed July 4, 2025, and widely called the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, added section 174A. For tax years beginning after December 31, 2024:

  • Domestic research or experimental expenditures can once again be deducted in the year paid or incurred.
  • You can choose instead to capitalize them and amortize over at least 60 months, beginning when benefits are first realized.
  • Software development costs count as research or experimental expenditures.
  • Foreign research still has to be capitalized and amortized over 15 years under section 174.

The law also offered two transition options. Remaining unamortized domestic costs from 2022 through 2024 can be deducted in the first tax year beginning after 2024 or spread across that year and the next. Small businesses meeting the gross receipts test, $31 million for that year according to Grant Thornton’s summary of Rev. Proc. 2025-28, could apply section 174A retroactively to tax years beginning after 2021 through amended returns. That deadline was the earlier of July 6, 2026, or the refund claim deadline, so the window is now closed.

The change affects the research credit directly: the first prong of the four-part test now points to domestic research expenditures under section 174A rather than the old section 174.

The 280C choice: full credit or reduced credit

Under section 280C(c), taking the full research credit reduces your section 174A deduction, or the amount you capitalize, by the credit amount. The alternative is electing a reduced credit, 79% of the full amount, and keeping the whole deduction.

The 79% has a logic to it. It’s 100% minus the 21% corporate rate, which produces a simple decision rule (our analysis):

  • If your marginal rate is 21%, as it is for most C corporations, both options deliver the same current-year benefit.
  • If your marginal rate is above 21%, as it is for many pass-through owners, the reduced credit usually wins.
  • If your marginal rate is under 21%, or you’re in a loss position, the full credit usually comes out ahead in the current year, though the smaller deduction reduces your net operating loss.

Applying it to the $52,500 credit from the earlier example:

Marginal tax rateFull credit, after lost deductionReduced creditBetter choice
12%$52,500 − $6,300 = $46,200$41,475Full credit
21%$52,500 − $11,025 = $41,475$41,475No difference
24%$52,500 − $12,600 = $39,900$41,475Reduced credit
37%$52,500 − $19,425 = $33,075$41,475Reduced credit

This is a simplification. It leaves out state taxes, timing differences if you capitalize under section 174A(c) and other deductions linked to taxable income. Still, it shows why making the election out of habit can cost a pass-through owner real money.

The timing is rigid. The Form 6765 instructions say the election has to be made on an original, timely filed return, extensions included. It can’t be made or changed on an amended return and can’t be revoked for that year.

Form 6765 Section G becomes required

Section G of Form 6765 collects information by business component: what each project was, what information you were trying to discover and the QREs tied to it. It’s optional for tax years beginning before 2026. For tax years beginning after 2025, meaning calendar-year 2026 returns filed in 2027, it’s mandatory unless an exception applies:

  • Certain qualified small businesses taking the payroll tax election, as the instructions describe.
  • Claims where the controlled group’s QREs are $1.5 million or less and average gross receipts for the prior three years are $50 million or less, filed on an original return.

When Section G applies, you report at least 80% of total QREs by business component, across no more than 50 components, and group the rest. Section E separately asks for the number of business components, officer wages included in QREs, whether QREs relate to an acquisition or disposition and whether you’ve identified new expense categories.

In practice: if you track research by project throughout 2026, Section G is just a reporting task. If you’ve been estimating QREs from department payroll totals after year-end, you’ll be reconstructing project detail against a deadline.

Scientist recording experiment results for research credit records

Records that hold up in an exam

You claim the R&D tax credit on a return, but you win or lose it on records. Keep these for each year you claim:

  • A project list with dates and the technical uncertainty each project tackled.
  • Evidence of experimentation: design documents, test plans, test results, failed prototypes, version-control history and sprint tickets.
  • Time records tying each person’s time to projects. Where you don’t track time, real-time estimates from project leads are much stronger than surveys taken months later.
  • Payroll reports linking claimed wages to Forms W-2.
  • Contracts for contractor work and customer-funded projects, showing who carries the risk and who owns the results.
  • Cloud and supply invoices that separate research environments and prototype materials from production costs.

The usual weak spot in disputes is a claim that can’t link specific wages to specific projects. Build that link as the work happens.

Claiming the research credit on an amended return

You can generally claim a missed research credit on an amended return or, for partnerships under the centralized audit regime, through an administrative adjustment request. The Form 6765 instructions say such a refund claim has to include specific information to be valid, and they point to the IRS’s published requirements for research credit refund claims. Check those requirements before filing, since a claim lacking them can be treated as invalid. The payroll election and the 280C election, on the other hand, can’t be made late on an amended return.

State research credits

Many states run their own research credits, with different definitions, rates, caps and carryforward periods. Some follow the federal definition of QREs and others don’t. Check your state revenue department’s rules before assuming the federal numbers carry over as is.

Common mistakes

  1. Counting every hour of engineering time. Routine development, post-release bug fixes and customer-specific adaptation fail the four-part test.
  2. Overlooking the funded-research exclusion. Fixed-fee development for a customer who owns the result is generally the customer’s research, not yours.
  3. Including offshore work. Foreign research is excluded from the credit and amortized over 15 years for deduction purposes.
  4. Missing the payroll election deadline. It has to go on the original return, filed on time with extensions.
  5. Making the 280C election out of habit. Run the numbers at your real marginal rate.
  6. Reconstructing records at year-end. Section G makes project-level data mandatory for many 2026 claims.
  7. Counting depreciable equipment as supplies. Equipment you depreciate doesn’t qualify as a supply cost.

For other areas where the IRS lets you fix mistakes through a formal process, see our coverage of the IRS EPCRS update for retirement plan corrections.

Our Take / Expert Perspective

Our take: the 2025 law made the R&D tax credit easier to value and harder to claim sloppily.

For three years, capitalization under the old section 174 meant research spending pushed taxable income up, and for many smaller companies the credit mainly offset a tax bill the law itself had produced. With section 174A bringing back the deduction, the credit is once again a pure incentive stacked on a deduction. That makes it more worth claiming and more tempting to overclaim.

The cost has shifted to documentation. Mandatory Section G for 2026 returns means the IRS will see every claim project by project, along with the information sought for each. The old shortcut of taking payroll by department, applying percentages and filing produces a Section G that reads like guesswork. Our forecast, and it’s only a forecast: vague business component descriptions will attract more questions beginning with returns filed in 2027.

Who gains? Startups doing genuine engineering work. They get the payroll offset, the 6% rate in their early years and a Section G exception while they’re small. Who loses? Companies that relied on providers estimating QREs from job titles, and pass-through owners who never revisited their 280C election.

Our recommendation: before December 31, set up project-level time tracking for everyone whose work might qualify, and make the 280C decision with your actual marginal rate in front of you.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the R&D tax credit?

It’s a federal credit under section 41 of the Internal Revenue Code for increasing research activities. It cuts tax dollar for dollar based on qualified research expenses like wages, supplies, computer rental and 65% of contract research. You claim it on Form 6765.

Who qualifies for the research and development tax credit?

Any business whose projects pass the four-part test: costs treated as domestic research under section 174A, work that’s technological in nature, an aim of a new or improved business component and a process of experimentation. The industry doesn’t matter; the nature of the work does.

How much is the R&D tax credit worth?

Under the alternative simplified credit, it’s 14% of qualified research expenses above half the prior three-year average. With flat spending, that comes to roughly 7% of QREs. Companies with no QREs in any of the prior three years get 6%.

Can a startup with no profit use the research credit?

Yes, if it’s a qualified small business: gross receipts below $5 million for the year and no gross receipts before the five-year period ending that year. It can elect up to $500,000 a year against the employer share of social security and Medicare taxes, claimed on Form 8974.

Does software development qualify?

It can qualify for the R&D tax credit. Section 174A treats software development costs as research or experimental expenditures, and software projects often satisfy the four-part test when they resolve genuine technical uncertainty. Routine coding, maintenance and customer-specific configuration usually don’t qualify.

What is Form 6765 used for?

Form 6765 is where you calculate and claim the research credit, pick the regular or simplified method, make the 280C and payroll elections and report business component detail in Section G. Partnerships and S corporations have to file it to claim the credit.

This article is for general information only and is not tax, accounting or financial advice. Consult a licensed CPA or financial professional for your situation.

Sources

Photos: ThisisEngineering, xing bowen and National Cancer Institute on Unsplash.

Sachin Garg Avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About aiandblog

Practical reporting on AI, SaaS, compliance and finance. We cite primary sources and correct mistakes in the open. Read our editorial policy.