Remote I-9 Verification: The Two Legal Ways to Do It

The two legal ways to do remote I-9 verification: the DHS alternative procedure for E-Verify employers, and an authorized representative for everyone else.

Remote I-9 verification: HR professional on a live video call

Last updated: November 6, 2026

Reviewed by an HR compliance professional (PHR, SHRM-CP) on November 8, 2026.

Remote I-9 verification is legal, but there are only two ways to do it. Employers enrolled in E-Verify can use a Department of Homeland Security alternative procedure that checks documents over live video. Everyone else has to send someone, known as an authorized representative, to look at the original documents in person for the company. Under either route, a photo emailed to HR isn’t enough by itself.

Short answer: Remote I-9 verification is how you complete Form I-9 Section 2 without meeting a new hire face to face. E-Verify employers in good standing can review document copies, then view the same originals on a live video call and keep the copies. Other employers must use an authorized representative who examines the documents in person and signs Section 2 for them.
Key takeaways

  • Only employers participating in E-Verify in good standing at the hiring site can use the DHS alternative procedure.
  • It has three steps: review copies (front and back), hold a live video call with the same documents and keep clear copies.
  • You may offer it to remote hires alone, but you can’t decide who qualifies based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin.
  • Any employer can appoint an authorized representative, like a notary or agent, to examine documents in person, and the employer remains liable for their errors.
  • Section 2 is still due within three business days of the first day of work, so a Monday start means Section 2 by Thursday.

What is remote I-9 verification?

Remote I-9 verification means completing the employer’s section of Form I-9, Section 2, without the employer meeting the new hire in person. It matters most to remote-first companies and anyone hiring people who live far from an office.

The baseline rule is unchanged. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Handbook for Employers M-274 says that, generally, you or your authorized representative have to review the employee’s documents in their physical presence. Remote I-9 verification works either by fitting an exception to that rule or by sending someone in your place.

Common situations: a remote-first startup hiring in several states, a company adding one salesperson nowhere near an office, or a seasonal hiring rush where HR can’t meet everyone on day one. Each raises the same question: who looks at the original documents, and how? Under either option, an emailed scan or phone photo alone doesn’t answer it.

Option 1: The DHS alternative procedure for E-Verify employers

The alternative procedure is the only approved way to examine Form I-9 documents by video. The USCIS page on remote examination of documents says you can use it only if you participate in E-Verify in good standing at the hiring sites where you use it.

USCIS defines good standing in three parts:

  • You’re enrolled in E-Verify at every hiring site using the alternative procedure.
  • You run E-Verify to confirm employment eligibility for new hires in the United States.
  • You meet all other E-Verify program requirements.

New E-Verify enrollees and users take a tutorial that includes fraudulent document awareness training. Employers who are already enrolled can retake it whenever they like, and doing so before your first video session is a good idea.

Who you can offer it to

If you offer the alternative procedure at an E-Verify hiring site, you have to offer it consistently to every new employee there. USCIS does permit one split: offering it to remote hires only while examining documents in person for onsite and hybrid staff.

That split comes with a strict condition. You can’t adopt it for a discriminatory purpose or treat employees differently based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin, for example by deciding some employees can’t use remote examination.

How the alternative procedure works, step by step

  1. Have the employee send copies of the Form I-9 documents they’ve chosen, front and back if two-sided. An acceptable receipt works too.
  2. Look over the copies to confirm they reasonably appear genuine and relate to the employee.
  3. Run a live video call where the employee shows the same documents they sent, so you can check them against the person.
  4. Fill in Section 2. On the 08/01/2023 or 01/20/2025 edition of Form I-9, tick the box in the Additional Information field indicating you used an alternative procedure.
  5. Open the E-Verify case for the new hire, just as you would for anyone hired at that site.
  6. Retain a clear, readable copy of every document you reviewed, front and back.

Running the video call well

USCIS sets the three steps, but how you run the call is your decision. These habits turn it into a real check instead of a box-ticking exercise:

  • Test the video link with the employee ahead of time so you don’t lose the first five minutes to audio problems.
  • Keep the copies open on your screen and ask the employee to hold each original up to the camera, front first, then back.
  • Check the photo on the document against the person on screen, and the name and numbers against the copies you received.
  • If something about a document looks off, say so calmly and let the employee pick a different acceptable document. Don’t suggest one.
  • Write the date and time of the call on your own checklist so your records show when Section 2 was done.

The call itself normally takes a few minutes per employee. Most of the time goes into preparing for it.

Employee joining a video meeting from a laptop at home

Option 2: An authorized representative (any employer)

Without E-Verify, remote I-9 verification means sending someone to view the documents in person. The M-274 lets you designate, hire or contract with any person to complete Section 2 or Supplement B for you, such as personnel officers, foremen, notaries public or agents. That person becomes your authorized representative.

Three handbook rules govern how this works:

  • You remain liable. Any Form I-9 violation is on you, including mistakes made by your authorized representative.
  • You don’t need a contract. USCIS doesn’t require a contract or specific agreement with the representative for Form I-9 purposes, though a written instruction sheet protects you.
  • A notary isn’t acting as a notary. When a notary public serves as your authorized representative, they aren’t acting in that role and shouldn’t put a notary seal on Form I-9.

The representative has to do everything the employer would: physically examine the original documents, fill in Section 2, then sign and date it.

How to brief an authorized representative

A representative who’s never handled a Form I-9 is the weak link in this option. Include a one-page instruction sheet with the blank form that covers:

  • The deadline: Section 2 within three business days of the first day of work.
  • That the employee picks which documents to present, either one from List A or one from List B plus one from List C.
  • That the representative has to see the original documents in person, not photos.
  • What to complete, sign and date in Section 2, and that the form gets no notary seal.
  • How and when to send the finished form back to you securely.

Check the form the day it comes back. Errors are much easier to correct while the employee and representative are still easy to reach.

Alternative procedure vs authorized representative

DHS alternative procedureAuthorized representative
Who can use itEmployers in E-Verify, in good standing at that siteAny employer
How documents are examinedCopies first, then the same originals on a live video callOriginals, in person
E-Verify neededYesNo
Copies of documentsMust keep clear copies, front and backNot required by this rule
Form I-9 markingCheck the alternative procedure box in Section 2None special
Who is liableThe employerThe employer, including for the representative’s errors
Main riskApplying it inconsistently at a siteChoosing an untrained representative

For most remote-first companies already on E-Verify, the alternative procedure is quicker and cheaper. For employers outside E-Verify, an authorized representative is the only legal remote option.

Weigh cost and control as well. A notary or staffing agent acting as representative may charge per visit, and you rely on their availability within a three-business-day window. The video route uses staff time instead and keeps the whole check within your HR team, which makes training and consistency easier.

Timing: the three-business-day rule still applies

Remote I-9 verification doesn’t give you extra time. The M-274 says the employer must complete Section 2 within three business days of the employee’s first day of work. The handbook’s own example: an employee starting Monday needs Section 2 done by Thursday.

Book the video call or in-person meeting before day one. Shipping delays, time zones and employees without webcams are the usual reasons remote I-9 verification runs late.

Remote reverification and rehires

The alternative procedure also applies to reverification and rehires. When you use it for either, tick the alternative procedure box in Supplement B on the 08/01/2023 or 01/20/2025 edition of Form I-9. USCIS adds one instruction for reverification: don’t create a new E-Verify case.

An authorized representative can complete Supplement B as well, following the same rules as Section 2.

Here’s a typical case: a remote employee in another state has an Employment Authorization Document expiring next month. An E-Verify employer can reverify over video using the same three steps and tick the box in Supplement B. An employer outside E-Verify sends an authorized representative to view the new document in person. Either way, it has to be done by the expiration date.

Keeping document copies

With the alternative procedure, keeping copies is mandatory. USCIS says to retain a clear copy of every document examined, front and back if two-sided, on paper, electronically or both, for the full length of employment plus the required period after it ends.

The copies serve a purpose. In an internal audit or federal inspection, they let a reviewer judge whether the documents shown on video looked genuine and related to the employee. If a federal inspector audits your Forms I-9, you have to make them available.

Handle the copies as sensitive records, since they show passport numbers, dates of birth and photos. Restrict who can open them, store them with the Form I-9 records instead of in shared folders, and use the same retention date as the form.

Remote worker at a home desk with a laptop and a mug

A remote I-9 verification checklist for HR

This is the routine we’d follow for a remote hire. It’s based on the USCIS rules above; the sequence is our recommendation.

WhenTaskOption
Offer acceptedSend Form I-9 Section 1 instructions and the Lists of Acceptable Documents; never suggest which documents to useBoth
Offer acceptedBook the video call, or book the authorized representativeBoth
By day 1Employee completes Section 1Both
Before the callReceive document copies, front and backAlternative procedure
Day 1 to 3Hold the live video call with the same documentsAlternative procedure
Day 1 to 3Representative examines originals in personAuthorized representative
By business day 3Complete Section 2; check the alternative procedure box if usedBoth
By business day 3Create the E-Verify caseAlternative procedure
Same dayFile the document copies with the Form I-9Alternative procedure

If a call falls through because of a dropped connection or a missing document, rebook it within the three-business-day window. If you can’t, an authorized representative can still complete Section 2 in person, but the deadline stays the same. Record what happened in a short memo filed with the Form I-9.

6 costly remote I-9 verification mistakes

  1. Using video without E-Verify. The alternative procedure is limited to E-Verify employers in good standing. Everyone else needs an authorized representative.
  2. Taking copies without a live call. The procedure has three steps, and dropping the video step breaks it.
  3. Selecting who gets remote examination by status or origin. Remote-only is fine; choosing employees by citizenship, immigration status or national origin isn’t.
  4. Missing the checkbox. Section 2 (or Supplement B) has to show that an alternative procedure was used.
  5. Not keeping clear copies. With the alternative procedure, front-and-back copies are a requirement, not just good practice.
  6. Having a notary stamp the form. A notary working as your authorized representative isn’t notarizing anything and shouldn’t apply a seal.
Man working on a laptop in a meeting room

Our Take / Expert Perspective

Our take: remote I-9 verification has quietly become another reason small employers sign up for E-Verify. Without it, every remote hire means finding and briefing an authorized representative in another city, and you own the liability for their mistakes. With it, a 15-minute video call does the job, provided you follow all three steps and keep the copies.

The catch is that E-Verify carries its own obligations. You have to use it for every new hire at that site, and in states with E-Verify mandates you may have to regardless. For remote-first teams, that usually tips the scales toward enrolling.

The real danger isn’t the technology but inconsistency. A company where one manager runs video calls while another insists on in-person checks for some hires and not others is setting itself up for a discrimination problem. Write a single remote I-9 verification policy for each hiring site and apply it to everyone it covers.

Our forecast: with more states requiring E-Verify and remote hiring still common, the alternative procedure will likely become the standard for distributed teams, and audits will look closely at whether the copies and checkboxes are in place.

What to do now: put in writing which option each hiring site uses, train whoever runs the calls and add the copies step to your I-9 checklist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can any employer check I-9 documents over video?

No. The DHS alternative procedure, including the live video call, is only for employers participating in E-Verify in good standing. Other employers need an authorized representative to examine the documents in person.

Can a notary complete Form I-9 for a remote employee?

Yes, as your authorized representative. The notary examines the original documents in person and completes Section 2 for you, but isn’t acting as a notary and shouldn’t add a seal. Your company stays liable for any errors.

Can I use the alternative procedure only for remote hires?

Yes. USCIS lets you offer it only to remote hires while examining documents in person for onsite and hybrid staff, provided the choice isn’t discriminatory and doesn’t treat people differently by citizenship, immigration status or national origin.

Do I have to keep copies of documents for remote I-9 verification?

Under the alternative procedure, yes. Keep clear front-and-back copies for the whole time the employee works for you plus the retention period after they leave, and hand them over if a federal inspector asks.

Can reverification be done remotely?

Yes. E-Verify employers can apply the alternative procedure to reverification and rehires and tick the box in Supplement B. Don’t open a new E-Verify case for a reverification.

Is a scanned or photographed document enough for Form I-9?

Not by itself. With the alternative procedure, copies are just the first step; you also have to see the same original documents on a live video call. Without E-Verify, someone has to examine the originals in person.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws differ by state, province and country; consult a qualified attorney for your situation.

Photos: Vitaly Gariev, Bluestonex, Helena Lopes and Creatopy on Unsplash.

Sources

Sachin Garg Avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About aiandblog

Practical reporting on AI, SaaS, compliance and finance. We cite primary sources and correct mistakes in the open. Read our editorial policy.