I-9 Reverification: When and How to Use Supplement B

Who needs I-9 reverification, when it’s due, how to complete Supplement B step by step, and what changed for automatic EAD extensions in 2025.

I-9 reverification deadline: calendar with red pins marking dates

Last updated: November 6, 2026

Reviewed by an HR compliance professional (PHR, SHRM-CP) on November 8, 2026.

I-9 reverification is the step you take when an employee’s temporary right to work in the U.S. is close to expiring. It’s recorded on Form I-9 Supplement B and must be finished no later than the day the authorization ends. Miss the timing or mishandle the documents and you end up either employing someone without proof they can work, or asking for paperwork the law doesn’t let you demand.

Short answer: I-9 reverification is how you confirm that a current employee with expiring work authorization can still legally work. By the expiration date, you fill in a block of Form I-9 Supplement B and record a List A or List C document the employee picks. It never applies to U.S. citizens, green cards, U.S. passports or List B documents.
Key takeaways

  • Reverify by the date the employee’s work authorization expires at the latest, then attach Supplement B to the original Form I-9.
  • Don’t reverify U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals, Permanent Resident Cards, U.S. passports or passport cards, or List B identity documents.
  • Most EAD renewals filed on or after October 30, 2025, no longer receive an automatic extension, so more employees now need reverification on the date their card expires.
  • You can’t use E-Verify to reverify employees with temporary work authorization.
  • If you rehire someone within three years of their original Form I-9, you can record it on Supplement B rather than a new form.

What is I-9 reverification?

I-9 reverification is the employer’s obligation to confirm, before the deadline passes, that an employee with time-limited work authorization is still allowed to work. You don’t complete a new Form I-9. Instead you add a dated block to Supplement B, Reverification and Rehire (formerly Section 3), and file it with the employee’s original form.

The requirement comes from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Handbook for Employers M-274, the official Form I-9 guide. It says you must reverify no later than the date employment authorization expires, and that you can’t continue employing someone who fails to provide proof of current authorization.

Supplement B covers three situations: reverifying expiring work authorization, recording a rehire within three years and recording a legal name change. We cover all three here, with the most space given to I-9 reverification, since that’s where the deadlines hurt.

Who needs I-9 reverification, and who never does

I-9 reverification applies only to employees whose work authorization has an end date. The M-274 is clear about who’s excluded: you never reverify U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals, and never when a U.S. passport, U.S. passport card, Permanent Resident Card or List B document expires.

SituationReverify?Why
U.S. citizen or noncitizen nationalNeverTheir work authorization doesn’t expire
Permanent Resident Card (green card) expiresNeverThe handbook lists it as a document that is never reverified
U.S. passport or passport card expiresNeverSame rule as above
Driver’s license or other List B document expiresNeverList B proves identity only, not work authorization
Employment Authorization Document (Form I-766) expiresYesWork authorization is time-limited
Temporary I-551 (ADIT) stamp in a passport or on Form I-94YesThe stamp is temporary; the employee must show a new document when it expires
Asylee or refugee who entered N/A as the expiration date in Section 1No, unless they chose to present a document that expires and requires reverificationTheir authorization doesn’t expire
Employee rehired within three yearsOptional Supplement B blockYou can use Supplement B or a new Form I-9

The temporary I-551 stamp has two deadlines in the handbook. If the employee showed a Form I-94 bearing the stamp and a photo, they must present the actual Permanent Resident Card when the stamp expires, or one year after the I-94 was issued if the stamp shows no expiration date. If they showed a foreign passport with the stamp, they must present a List A or List C document when the stamp expires, or one year after admission if there’s no date.

Two colleagues reviewing and signing paperwork together

When is I-9 reverification due?

I-9 reverification must be done by the date the employee’s work authorization expires. The form itself has no grace period. If the employee doesn’t produce a new acceptable document by that date, the handbook says you can’t keep employing them.

So there are two dates to track: the expiration date in Section 1 and the document expiration date in Section 2. Go by whichever one belongs to the authorization that’s actually ending. An expiring EAD is the case you’ll see most.

Receipts follow their own timing. During reverification of existing employees, the handbook accepts certain receipts, and an employee using one must present it by the date their employment authorization expires. The list is short: mostly a receipt for replacing a lost, stolen or damaged document, plus specific Form I-94 receipts. A receipt for a brand-new application isn’t acceptable.

The 2025 change to automatic EAD extensions

Many older reverification guides miss this change. Under a Department of Homeland Security interim final rule effective October 30, 2025 (90 FR 48799), a Form I-765 renewal filed on or after that date generally doesn’t automatically extend an expiring EAD anymore, unless a statute or Federal Register notice provides otherwise.

Employees in an eligible category who filed a timely renewal before October 30, 2025, may still have an automatic extension of up to 540 days from the Card Expires date while the renewal is pending. That extension ends sooner if USCIS rules on the application first. Section 5.0 of the M-274 also flags special limits for some Temporary Protected Status cases following the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.

In practice, for most renewals filed now, the date printed on the EAD is the actual deadline. Schedule reverification around that date, not around a pending renewal. If an employee tells you their card was extended, compare the category code and receipt notice with Section 5 of the handbook before relying on it.

How to complete Form I-9 Supplement B, step by step

Form I-9 Supplement B is a standalone page with several identical blocks. Each reverification, rehire or name change gets its own block, which you complete and sign before attaching the page to the employee’s original Form I-9.

Reverifying a current employee

  1. At the top of Supplement B, write the employee’s full name exactly as it appears on the original Form I-9.
  2. If the employee’s legal name has changed, fill in only the part that changed in the block’s New Name fields.
  3. Have the employee present any unexpired List A or List C document of their choice. Don’t suggest a specific document.
  4. Record the document title, number and expiration date in the block.
  5. Add your name, then sign and date the block.
  6. Attach the page to the original Form I-9 and store the two together.

If the employee’s last update was recorded on a Form I-9 version that’s no longer valid, use the current version’s Supplement B and attach it to the original form. Confirm the current edition on the USCIS Form I-9 page before printing.

Rehiring within three years

When you rehire someone within three years of the date their previous Form I-9 was completed, you can either use a Supplement B block or start a new Form I-9. Once three years have passed, a new Form I-9 is required.

  • Still authorized to work (for example, U.S. citizens and green card holders who presented a Form I-551): write their name, any name change and the rehire date, then sign and date. You don’t need new documents.
  • Authorization has expired: write the name, any name change and the rehire date, record the new List A or List C document and its expiration date, then sign and date.

When an employee legally changes their name, put the new name in the New Name fields of a Supplement B block and add your name, signature and date. This is required during a reverification or rehire, and at any other time the handbook recommends doing it as soon as you hear about the change. Ask for proof, such as a marriage certificate, and keep a copy with the Form I-9.

Keep every Supplement B page with the original Form I-9 for as long as you retain the form: three years after the hire date or one year after employment ends, whichever comes later. If you receive an inspection notice, the government will expect the reverification blocks to be part of the record.

One block records one event. If an employee needs another reverification a year later, use the next empty block on the same page, or attach a fresh Supplement B page once the blocks are full.

Monthly paper calendar on a desk

What documents can an employee show for reverification?

For I-9 reverification, the employee may present any unexpired List A or List C document, an unrestricted Social Security card included. The choice is theirs. You have to accept a document that reasonably appears genuine and relates to the person presenting it.

  • Accept: a new EAD, a foreign passport with a valid Form I-94 granting work authorization, an unrestricted Social Security card, or any other List A or List C document.
  • Reject: a restricted Social Security card, meaning one that says it’s valid for work only with DHS authorization. Ask for another List A or List C document instead.
  • Never request: List B documents. They establish identity, and you already checked that at hire.

If the employee originally completed an older version of Form I-9, they can pick any List A or List C document from the current version’s lists at reverification.

I-9 reverification and E-Verify

I-9 reverification doesn’t involve E-Verify at all. The M-274 says employers may not use E-Verify to reverify employees with temporary employment authorization. Reverification happens on paper (or in your electronic I-9 system) on Supplement B alone.

The only overlap is name changes. The handbook advises E-Verify employers to make sure employees report a legal name change to the Social Security Administration, which prevents mismatches down the line. If a non-legal name change leads you to complete a new Form I-9, confirm the new form in E-Verify; if you don’t create a new form, don’t open a new E-Verify case.

A simple I-9 reverification tracking system

Missed reverifications usually aren’t legal errors. They’re calendar errors. Below is the routine we’d put in place for a small HR team; it’s our recommendation, not a USCIS requirement.

WhenWhat to doWho
At hireLog every expiring work authorization date from Section 1 and Section 2 in one trackerHR
120 days before expirySend the employee a neutral reminder that their authorization date is coming upHR
90 days beforeNote whether a renewal has been filed and when; check whether any automatic extension applies under Section 5 of the M-274HR
30 days beforeConfirm the reverification appointmentHR, manager
On or before the expiration dateComplete the Supplement B block from the document the employee choosesHR
After reverificationUpdate the tracker with the next expiration dateHR

Send every employee with an expiring date the same reminder in the same words. Treating people differently here is exactly what the handbook warns about.

Here’s a neutral reminder to adapt. Use identical wording for everyone with an expiring date:

Hi [Name], our records show that the work authorization you gave us when you joined has an end date of [date]. Before that date we’ll need to update your Form I-9. You can bring any unexpired document from List A or List C of the Form I-9 Lists of Acceptable Documents, and the choice is yours. Please let us know if you have questions, and reply with a time that works for a short meeting before [date].

Leave out any guesses about the employee’s immigration case. Request only what the form requires, and file a copy of each reminder with your I-9 records.

HR manager meeting an employee at a desk

7 common I-9 reverification mistakes

  1. Reverifying people who don’t need it. Green card holders, U.S. citizens and U.S. passport holders are exempt. Reverifying them based on citizenship, immigration status or national origin can be an unfair documentary practice under the Immigration and Nationality Act.
  2. Completing a new Form I-9 for a current employee. The handbook says to fill in a Supplement B block and attach it to the original form.
  3. Letting the expiration date pass. No grace period is built in. Start tracking dates on day one.
  4. Assuming an EAD got an automatic extension. For most renewals filed on or after October 30, 2025, it didn’t.
  5. Telling the employee what document to bring. The employee picks from List A or List C.
  6. Taking a restricted Social Security card. It doesn’t work for reverification.
  7. Reverifying through E-Verify. E-Verify can’t be used for this.

Our Take / Expert Perspective

Our take: the October 2025 rule turned I-9 reverification from an occasional task into a standing payroll risk. Before it, many employees with pending EAD renewals had months of automatic cover, so HR teams could be relaxed about expiration dates. Now, for most renewals filed after October 29, 2025, the date on the card is the one that counts.

The employers who get burned are the ones handling reverification from memory: small companies with a few visa holders and no tracker. The ones who come out fine are dull about it. They log every date at hire, remind everyone in the same way and complete Supplement B before the deadline, not on it.

There’s a knock-on effect too. If renewals take longer than the time left on the card, employees may hit a gap in work authorization that no HR paperwork can close. That’s a staffing problem rather than a form problem, and it falls on managers with little notice.

Our forecast: employees will ask more often whether they can keep working while a renewal is pending, and HR will be under more pressure to get the answer right. Check each case against Section 5 of the M-274.

What to do this week: pull every expiring work authorization date in the company into one sheet, flag anything within 120 days and check each against the post-October 2025 extension rules.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far in advance can I do I-9 reverification?

The rule sets the latest date, not the earliest: reverification has to happen by the expiration date. In practice, start the conversation well in advance so the employee has time to get a new document. Handle every employee with an expiring date the same way.

Do green card holders need I-9 reverification?

No. You never reverify when a Permanent Resident Card expires. The exception is a temporary I-551 stamp in a passport or on a Form I-94, which does need reverification when it expires.

What is Form I-9 Supplement B?

Form I-9 Supplement B, Reverification and Rehire, took the place of Section 3 on the older form. Employers use it to reverify expiring work authorization, record a rehire within three years or record a legal name change, and attach it to the employee’s original Form I-9.

What happens if an employee can’t show a new document by the expiration date?

The M-274 says you can’t keep employing someone who doesn’t provide proof of current employment authorization. Speak with employment counsel before you act, because termination decisions carry their own legal questions.

Can I use E-Verify for I-9 reverification?

No. According to the handbook, employers may not use E-Verify to reverify employees with temporary employment authorization. Reverification is done on Supplement B only.

Do I need a new Form I-9 when I rehire someone?

Only when more than three years have passed since their previous Form I-9 was completed. Inside three years, you can choose either a Supplement B block or a new Form I-9.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws differ by state, province and country; consult a qualified attorney for your situation.

Photos: Towfiqu barbhuiya, Gabrielle Henderson, Eric Rothermel and Amy Hirschi on Unsplash.

Sources

Sachin Garg Avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About aiandblog

Practical reporting on AI, SaaS, compliance and finance. We cite primary sources and correct mistakes in the open. Read our editorial policy.